Robateau v The Queen; Pipersburgh v The Queen
| Jurisdiction | Belize |
| Court | Court of Appeal (Belize) |
| Judge | Carey, J.A.,MOTTLEY, P.,CAREY, J.A. |
| Judgment Date | 24 June 2005 |
| Neutral Citation | BZ 2005 CA 19 |
| Docket Number | Crim. Appeal 7 & 8 of 2004 |
| Date | 24 June 2005 |
Mottley, P.; Sosa, J.A.; Carey, J.A.
Crim. Appeal 7 & 8 of 2004
Court of Appeal
Criminal law - Murder — Attempted murder — Conviction — Death sentence and twenty years imprisonment respectively — Appeal — Appellants robbing workplace and killing 4 victims — Circumstantial evidence — Identification evidence — Previous knowledge of appellants by several witnesses — Coincidence of both appellants absenting themselves form work — Money bags removed from truck used by appellants to flee compound — Whether trial judge misdirecting jury — Finding of no irregularities to make trial unfair — Appeals dismissed.
Mr. Dean Lindo, S.C. with Mr. Michael Peyrefitte for Pipersburgh.
Mr. Orlando Fernandez with Mr. Hubert Elrington for Robateau.
Mr. Kirk Anderson, Director of Public Prosecution for Crown.
On 9th March, 2005, a majority of this Court dismissed these appeals against convictions for murder (counts 1 – 4) and attempted murder (count 5). There were also appeals against the sentence of death as regards the murder convictions and twenty years imprisonment which was imposed on count 5. When we promised on 7th October, 2004 that we would take time to consider and would give our reasons at a later date, we had hoped that would have taken place on 9th March and we very much regret it is only now possible to provide them. What follows represents the reasons of the majority.
These appellants were convicted for the murder on 18th June, 2002 of Fidel Mai (count 1), of Kevin Alvarez (count 2), of Cherry Tucker (count 3), of David Flores (count 4) and of attempted murder in respect of Karl Ventura (count 5) after a trial which lasted from 9th February to 24th March, 2004 before Gonzalez J and a jury.
Two of the victims, Fidel Mai and Kevin Alvarez, were security guards employed to KBH Ltd. which is a Company providing security services, including the escorting of cash from one location to another. On 18th June, 2002, Karl Ventura, a security guard with this organization went in the Company of Mai and Alvarez, who were armed with 9 mm Glock firearms to Bowen and Bowen Distributors, on Slaughterhouse Road, Belize City. Leaving Mai, the driver in the vehicle, Ventura and Alvarez passed through an office which was lit by fluorescent lighting into the warehouse where there was a table with three sealed Barclays Bank bags. On their way back to their vehicle, they were confronted by two men armed with guns which were being pointed at them. They were made to walk backwards to the warehouse. While one of these men held Ventura, the other man shot Alvarez who fell. Ventura struggled with the other man, trying to get his gun. This man instructed the man who had shot Alvarez to shoot Ventura. That man came close to him and shot him in his shoulder. He lost consciousness and came to, in hospital. He described the shooter as a “red-skin male person” whom he had seen before, in May, 2002 (which would have been shortly before the incident) at Bowen & Bowen where he had then been posted. He had seen him every day for a one week period drive through the gate at Bowen & Bowen. Before the judge and jury, he identified the appellant Patrick Robateau as the person who shot Alvarez and himself.
John Ventura, also a witness for the prosecution, was a security guard employed at KBH and posted at Bowen & Bowen Distributors Centre, at Slaughterhouse Road. On 18th June at 7:45 p.m. he saw Robateau park a red-coloured Coca Cola truck near a door at the side of an office on the compound of Bowen & Bowen. Mr. Ventura was then at the back gate. Another guard, Virgilio Requena, was at the entrance. Mr. Ventura observed Pipersburgh walk from the office towards the main gate where a struggle ensued between them. This prompted him to approach them, in the meantime charging his shotgun, but he was afraid to fire because both men were close together. Immediately, he felt something pressing in his left side. When he looked, he saw it was Patrick Robateau who ordered him to drop his weapon. He reacted by taking to his heels and jumped over a fence. Eventually he stopped a passing car and made a report to the police. When he returned with the police, the Coca Cola truck was no longer there.
This witness spoke to his knowledge of both appellants. He met Robateau while both served in the Belize Defence Force (BDF) during 1997 over a period of six months. He would see him twice a month in that period. Thereafter he saw him almost daily for over an eight month period while he was posted at Bowen & Bowen where Robateau was a driver of a “Crystal” truck that Robateau used, to deliver a brand of drinking water. On the occasion he saw this appellant dismount from the Coca Cola truck, he saw his right-hand side for fifteen seconds from a distance of forty to forty-five feet with the aid of street lights around the perimeter of the premises. At the time when he felt something pressed in his side and looked, he saw Robateau's face for about fifteen seconds.
With respect to Pipersburgh, he has known this appellant for the eight months he has been posted at Bowen & Bowen and saw him quite often on a daily basis in the evenings at about 6:00 p.m. The struggle between Pipersburgh and Requena, while he stood five metres off, lasted about thirty seconds, and there were lights around the entrance at the gate where they were.
Virgilio Requena was another KBH security guard at Bowen & Bowen who came into contact with these appellants. On 18th June, 2002 at 5:00 p.m., he reported at Bowen & Bowen where he had been assigned for three months. At 6:00 p.m. when he was on guard at the entrance gate, he saw a ‘Crystal’ truck driven by Robateau enter through the main gate and make its way to a shed where empties are discharged. After the driver loaded the truck, he went into the office. Sometime after that, by which time night had fallen, he made his way some twenty-five yards from the main gate where he could see into the office. He saw Robateau in the office, and indicated to him that he wanted to go to sleep. Robateau showed him nine fingers which he understood to mean that Robateau wanted nine minutes more.
There came a time when the cashier left. Shortly after that, he saw a person whom he described as a “dark skin male person” leaving through the office door. That person, he later identified as Pipersburgh. He believed that Pipersburgh would go through the gate but instead he came up to him and pressed something in his side, telling him to hand over his gun. His reply was — “stop playing”. When Pipersburgh grabbed at his gun, a 12 gauge shot-gun, he realized that Pipersburgh was serious. A struggle for the gun ensued and both ended on the ground. Requena was hit on his head causing him to release the gun. He lost consciousness and came to, in a drain by the main gate.
He also testified to his prior knowledge of Pipersburgh. For a three month period before the incident, he would see Pipersburgh driving his truck through the gate of Bowen & Bowen on the occasions he was posted there. This would occur about three days per week. The reason why, in reference to Pipersburgh, he said dark complexion person or the like, was that he did not know his name.
Another prosecution witness Albert Zelaya, describing himself as a “side clerk”, spoke to Robateau's presence at Bowen & Bowen on the relevant date. His duties were to go out with the driver to deliver water to customers. Robateau was his driver on that date. He left the premises at 5:45 p.m. while Robateau was in the main office.
At about the time of the incident, Corporal Jorge Ayala and other police officers were on mobile patrol in the area. They received a report from a security guard at the gate of Bowen & Bowen. As an internal gate was being opened, Corporal Ayala heard gun shots coming from the direction of the distribution office. They went in the direction of the gun shots. Nearing the office, he saw a dark complexion man about six feet tall approaching. That man fired at them. An officer, Constable Salam, returned fire but he missed. At the same time, he noticed a red Coca Cola truck drive out from the compound onto Slaughterhouse Road, stopping just before reaching the gate and the man who had fired at them, got into the passenger side of the truck which then sped off. The police went in pursuit but lost sight of the truck. A radio transmission caused them to go to an area called Coral Grove and there the Coca Cola truck was seen parked in a cul-de-sac.
From the cab of this truck, the police recovered a 9 mm gun, a 38 pistol, three “white bags with blue markings” — the Barclay's Bank money bags, and two 12 gauge shot-guns. The windshield of the truck showed a bullet hole. The police officer who fired at the truck was Constable Garay. He observed the vehicle stop in the cul-de-sac and two men, one of whom was armed, leave the vehicle and run off. He challenged them, ordering them to stop, one made off into the bushes, the other at whom he fired, fell. He waited for assistance. That presumably allowed that person to escape. He confirmed the finding of a Glock 9 mm handgun and a 38 pistol. There was a search of the immediate area. He found a Toyota Camry and a brown station wagon taxi. Next to the Camry, he found the body of a woman, Cherry Tucker. Inside the car on the passenger side, he saw the body of David Flores. Cherry Tucker had picked up Flores at his home the evening of 18th June, 2002.
Essentially, that represented the direct evidence of the shooting in the Bowen & Bowen compound. The remainder of the evidence comprises the circumstantial evidence linking the appellants with the charges against them.
It is convenient to deal first with the medical evidence. It is enough to say that all the victims...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations