Mestizo et Al v Gabourel et Al

JurisdictionBelize
CourtSupreme Court (Belize)
JudgeSONYA YOUNG
Judgment Date18 September 2017
Neutral CitationBZ 2017 SC 37
Docket NumberCLAIM NO. 668 OF 2016 CLAIM NO. 671 OF 2016 CLAIM NO. 699 OF 2016 CLAIM NO. 700 OF 2016
Date18 September 2017
Miguel Angel Mestizo
CLAIMANT
and
Robert Gabourel
1 st DEFENDANT
Ernesto Gabourel
2 nd DEFENDANT
Ernest Gabourel
1 st ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Robert Gabourel
2 nd ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Sabina Carballo
CLAIMANT
and
Robert Gabourel
1 st DEFENDANT
Ernesto Gabourel
2 nd DEFENDANT
Ernest Gabourel
1 st ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Robert Gabourel
2 nd ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Francisco De Paz
CLAIMANT
and
Robert Gabourel
1 st DEFENDANT
Ernesto Gabourel
2 nd DEFENDANT
Ernest Gabourel
1 st ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Robert Gabourel
2 nd ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Dora Prado
CLAIMANT
and
Robert Gabourel
1 st DEFENDANT
Ernesto Gabourel
2 nd DEFENDANT
Ernest Gabourel
1 st ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Robert Gabourel
2 nd ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Jose Romero
CLAIMANT
and
Robert Gabourel
1 st DEFENDANT
Ernesto Gabourel
2 nd DEFENDANT
Ernest Gabourel
1 st ANCILLARY CLAIMANT
Robert Gabourel
2 nd ANCILLARY CLAIMANT

BEFORE the Honourable Madam Justice Sonya Young

CLAIM NO. 668 OF 2016

CLAIM NO. 670 of 2016

CLAIM NO. 671 OF 2016

CLAIM NO. 699 OF 2016

CLAIM NO. 700 OF 2016

THE SUPREME COURT OF BELIZE A.D. 2017

Keywords: Civil Procedure — Counterclaim — No defence — Judgment on Admission

Cases Mentioned:

Muhammad v. ARY Properties Ltd (2016) EWHC 1098 — Rochez v. Williams Claim No. 179 of 2009 — Maharaj v. The Great Northern Insurance Company Ltd et al Civil Appeal No. P198 of 2015.

Legislation:

CPR 14 and18

Appearances:

Mr. Kevin Arthurs for the Claimants.

Mr. Hubert Elrington, SC for the Defendants.

RULING
1

The circumstances which give rise to this ruling are simple. The Counter-Defendants did not file a defence to the counterclaims herein within the twenty-eight days prescribed by Rule 18.9(2). They have made no application for extension of time in which to file such a defence either.

2

Counsel for the Counter-Claimants say that in accordance with Rule 18.12(2)(a) the Counter-Defendants are deemed to have admitted the counterclaim. Therefore, they (the Counter-Claimants) are entitled to judgment on admission and that such a judgment would ostensibly bring an end to the claims which ought to be struck out accordingly. At the first hearing of the Fixed Date Claim he orally moved an application to this effect. The court entertained the application and directed that written submissions be filed by both sides. I am grateful for the assistance rendered by both counsel.

3

In their submissions the Counter-Defendants strenuously opposed the application and maintained that the main proceedings, i.e. the claims are to be determined before the ancillary claims could be considered. This he said, was because the counterclaim was in fact a contingency claim. He valiantly insisted that the claim having been filed first had to be determined first and any judgment given therein could affect the counterclaim. It remained open to a judge only after trial of the main claim, to dismiss a counterclaim even where no counter-defence had been filed. He relied on Rule 18.6 and postulated that it is only where the court did not dismiss the counterclaim, that it change from a contingent claim, to an actual claim not subject to summary dismissal. On survival, the issues on the counterclaim become ripe for consideration and the Counter-Claimant gets a right to proceed with his claim.

4

Neither party was able to provide any precedent on this issue and considered it novel to the jurisdiction. The court for the reasons outlined below granted the Counter-Claimant's application.

Nature of a Counterclaim or Ancillary Claim:
5

Rule 18.2 prescribes:

  • “18.2 (1) An ancillary claim is to be treated as if it were a claim for the purposes of these Rules except as provided by this Rule.

  • (2) Particulars of an ancillary claim must be contained in or served with the ancillary claim form in Form 9.

  • (3) An ancillary claim form must include –

    • (a) the ancillary claimant's address for service in accordance with Rule 3.11; and

    • (b) a certificate of truth in accordance with Rule 3.12.

  • (4) The following Rules do not apply to ancillary claims –

    • (a) Rules 8.12 and 8.13 (time within which a claim form may be served);

    • (b) Part 12 (default judgments); and

    • (c) Part 14 (admissions) other than Rule 14.1 (1) and Rule 14.1 (2), Rule 14.3 and Rule 14.4

  • (5) Where the ancillary claim is a counterclaim by the defendant against a claimant (with or without any other person), the claimant is not required to file an acknowledgment of service and therefore Part 9 (Acknowledgment of Service) does not apply to the claimant.”

6

Blackstone's Civil Practice 2013 at paragraph 28.1 explains:

“The ability to bring a counterclaim within existing proceedings allows a defendant to wrest some of the initiative away from the claimant. Its main purpose, however, is to promote the general policy of ensuring that, so far as convenient, all issues between the parties are resolved together, with a view to saving costs, avoiding a multiplicity of claims and avoiding the risk of irreconcilable judgments.”

7

Although an ancillary claim is to be treated as a claim and under the UK rules a default judgment may be entered where no defence is filed in response, the Belize position is different. It is, in effect similar to the position of the UK additional claim against a third party. However, the need to file a defence to a counterclaim in Belize is of no less importance than it is in the UK.

8

The Counter-Defendants assert that Rule 18.9(1) gives a Counter-Defendant some discretion as to whether or not to file a defence. That Sub-rule reads:

“A person against whom an ancillary claim is made may file a defence.” The use of may is permissive, but the sub-rule has to be considered in light of Rule 18.9(3) which states clearly that: “ The rules relating to a defence to a claim apply to a defence to an ancillary claim except Part 12 (Default Judgment).” Therefore, Rule 10.2(1) applies with equal force to an Ancillary Defendant as it does to an ordinary Defendant and:

“A Defendant who wishes to defend all or part of a claim must file a defence …”

9

Muhammad v ARY Properties Ltd (2016) EWHC 1098(ch) reiterated that a defence to a counterclaim is not a formality and a full and detailed defence to the points made in the counterclaim is required. Therefore, if a party wishes to defend a counterclaim he must file a proper defence.

The issues now to be determined are:
10

1. Can a judgment on admission be entered when no defence is filed to a counterclaim within 28 days of service of the counterclaim.

2. Can a judgment be entered when no defence is filed to a counterclaim within 28 days of service of the counterclaim.

Can a judgment on admission be entered when no defence is filed to a counterclaim within 28 days of service of the counterclaim:
11

The court has, out of an abundance of caution, decided to deal with this issue since counsel for the Counter-Claimant insisted on referring to a judgment on admission. Rule 18.2(1) directs that an ancillary claim is to be treated as a claim except as provided by Rule 18. Rule 18.2(4) generally precludes the issuing of a judgment on admission where it states that Part 14 (Admissions) does not apply except Rules14.1(1), and (2), 14.3 and 14.4.

12

Rule 14.1(1) and (2) read:

“(1) A party may admit the truth of the whole or any part of any other party's case.

(1) A party may do this by giving notice in writing (such as a Statement of Case of by letter) before or after the issue of proceedings.”

13

In the present case there has been no such admission in writing. It is such a formal admission alone which ignites Rule 14.4:

  • “(1) Where a party makes an admission under Rule 14.1(2) (admission by notice in writing), any other party may apply for judgment on the admission.

  • (2) The terms of the judgment shall be such as it appears to the court that the applicant is entitled to on the admission.”

14

Rule 14.3 deals with admissions where the party is a minor or a patient and is irrelevant to these proceedings.

15

Briefly, then, it is only where a Counter-Defendant makes an admission in writing (before or after proceedings have been issued) that the Counter-Claimant or any other party may apply for a judgment on admission. There has been no such admission in this case and the Counter-Claimant therefore has no right to apply nor is he entitled to such.

Can a judgment be entered when no defence is filed to a counterclaim within 28 days of service of the counterclaim:
16

Rule 18.12 on which the Counter-Claimant relies is different. Its side note proclaims “ Special provisions relating to judgment on failure to...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex